Know what happens when you search Google for “tentacle pot pie”? Not much.* Let’s fix that! I created this tentacle pot pie for Babble using store bought dough. Easy and a wee bit creepy. Even if you’re not up for tentacles I found this chicken pot pie from Simply Recipes to be most delicious. Babble has also posted a short interview with me, thanks!
* (At least not when you have safe search turned on, oh my.)
· comments [61] · 10-21-2010 · categories:food · halloween ·
Hi, I'm Megan. I live in Seattle with Scott. I make stuff and give you tutorials on how to make it too. I also keep a blog of what I'm up to and links to good stuff from all over.
You can also find me at Twitter, Flickr, Ravelry, Facebook, Pinterest and Instagram. More about me and all this.This website is not affiliated or endorsed by Martha Stewart or Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia, Inc.
![[Trick or Treat cookies]](/images/sidebar/2010oct/trickortreatcookies_sidebar.jpg)
Trick-or-Treat Cookies: You have to break them open to find out which you get.
![[ALTEXT]](/images/sidebar/2010oct/zombieheadcheese_sidebar.jpg)
Zombie Head Cheese: It's simply cheese spread on a plastic skull. It's ghastly.
![[creepy hand made of meatloaf]](/images/sidebar/2010oct/meathand.jpg)
Meat Hand: it's made of meatloaf, I promise
![[human skull shaped cake]](/images/sidebar/2010oct/skullcake.jpg)
Skull Cake: I love this cake pan so darn much
![[crawly spider cakes]](/images/sidebar/2010oct/crawly.jpg)
Crawly Cakes: scary legs made from Pocky
![[knitted wig for Halloween]](/images/sidebar/2010oct/hallowig.jpg)
Hallowig: an easy to knit wig that is warm, great for trick-or-treating (over at Knitty)
![[orange pancakes decorated with dark syrup]](/images/sidebar/2010oct/pancakes.jpg)
Pumpkin Pancakes: with black cinnamon syrup
![[pot pies with extra dough tentacles]](/images/sidebar/2010oct/tentaclepotpie.jpg)
Tentacle Pot Pie: will you eat it or will it eat you?
Go see all of my how-tos.
Subscribe to my site in a reader.
61 responses so far ↓
1 World’s Strangest | Ten Terrific or Terrifying Treats for Halloween // Oct 13, 2011 at 6:25 am
[…] Reardon of Not Martha disguised pot pies as slithering monsters! Use your favorite pie recipe and dishes that can be […]
2 Ten Terrific or Terrifying Treats for Halloween - Cine Sopaipleto » Cine Sopaipleto // Oct 13, 2011 at 6:51 am
[…] Reardon of Not Martha disguised pot pies as slithering monsters! Use your favorite pie recipe and dishes that can be […]
3 Ten Terrific or Terrifying Treats for Halloween - Sopaipleto » Sopaipleto // Oct 13, 2011 at 7:39 am
[…] Reardon of Not Martha disguised pot pies as slithering monsters! Use your favorite pie recipe and dishes that can be […]
4 BigFatBaker // Oct 13, 2011 at 9:40 am
This is so cute! I’m thinking this should be dinner on date night with my BF.
5 Ghoulish Grub « The life and times of Justice Girl // Nov 8, 2011 at 1:49 pm
[…] main dish was a combo of (ironically) a recipe I found from Martha Stewart and an idea from Not Martha. I used our Mennonite pork sausage instead of turkey and made some other […]
6 lw // Jan 7, 2012 at 12:10 pm
I love your website, your super instructions and your first lines rock! Like this one:
‘Know what happens when you search Google for “tentacle pot pie”? Not much.’
Like ‘everyone’ searches for tentacle pot pie! You are wonderful, and funny, and incredibly creative! Thanks for sharing all you wonderful ideas and their fruition and thought processes with us! We really appreciate it!
7 A Tableful of Treats | La Crema Winery // Oct 22, 2012 at 5:22 pm
[…] Warm and hearty, this meal is the perfect dinner for a night of trickery, but you’ll need to be brave enough to cut through the tentacle crust first. Tentacle Pot Pie courtesy Not Martha […]
8 Creepy Halloween Treats // Oct 29, 2012 at 8:06 am
[…] Not Martha’s Tentacle Pot Pie […]
9 Halloween – gesammelte Links 2012 | Ja gut, aber … // Oct 30, 2012 at 12:49 pm
[…] Tentacle Pot Pie […]
10 Halloween 2013 - Food Ideas | The HostelBookers Blog // Oct 29, 2013 at 2:46 am
[…] Pot pie sea creatures anyone? Get the recipe. […]
11 3 Female DIY Interior Design Bloggers Aunt Renee Admires // Jun 15, 2014 at 2:26 pm
[…] design blogs written by women with children began with one blog post perfectly suited to me, “Tentacle Pot Pie“. Notmartha.org Blogger Megan Reardon won me as a fan with her unusual presentation of […]
Leave a Comment